Home
1999 Tax Letters
Ontario Budget Commentary
Federal Budget Commentary


2011 Ontario Budget Commentary
2010 Ontario Budget Commentary
  

ONTARIO BUDGET

COMMENTARY

MARCH 27, 2012

This analysis is of a general nature and is based on the Ontario Budget and other documents included with the Ontario Budget package and is presented only for the general information of our clients and staff. The proposals when enacted may vary substantially from the summary described herein. The reader is advised to refer to the amending legislation upon enactment. Specific professional advice should be obtained before taking action based upon the information provided in this commentary.


MARCH 27, 2012 ONTARIO BUDGET COMMENTARY
INDEX

1.0 INTRODUCTION

2.0 PERSONAL TAXES

2.1 Tax Rates
2.2 Individual Tax Credits

3.0 CORPORATE TAXES

3.1 Tax Rates
3.2 Business Education Tax (BET)
3.3 Ontario Apprenticeship Training Tax Credit (OATTC)
3.4 Research and Development (R&D)
3.5 Employer Health Tax (EHT)
3.6 Retail Sales Tax (RST) Refunds and Rebates
3.7 Loss Utilization

4.0 TAX ADMINISTRATION

4.1 Tax Collection Process
4.2 Corporate Tax Avoidance
4.3 Underground Economy

5.0 TOBACCO TAX ACT

6.0 MINING TAX ACT

1.0 INTRODUCTIONtop.gif (291 bytes)Top

Finance Minister Dwight Duncan delivered Ontario's 2012 Budget on March 27, 2012. The Budget is projecting a deficit of $15.3 billion in 2011-12, $1 billion lower than projected a year ago, and decreasing to $15.2 billion in 2012-13. The 2010 Budget put forward a plan to cut the deficit in half within five years and to eliminate it in eight years. The government remains on track to meet the fiscal targets outlined in the 2010 Budget beyond 2012-13. This includes steadily declining deficits and a return to a balanced budget by 2017-18.

There are very few tax related measures included in the Budget. Those that were introduced are summarized below.

BUDGETARY REVENUES
Actual
2009-2010
Actual
2010-2011
Interim
2011-2012
Budget Plan
2012-2013
Personal income tax $ 23,421 $ 23,711 $ 24,222 $ 25,797
Retail sales tax 17,059 18,813 20,885 21,135
Corporations tax 6,227 9,067 9,401 10,753
Education property tax 5,506 5,659 5,610 5,631
Employer health tax 4,545 4,733 5,028 5,149
Ontario Health Premiums 2,763 2,934 2,891 3,098
Gasoline and fuel tax 2,994 3,060 3,057 3,095
Other taxes 2,936 3,687 4,118 4,132
65,451 71,664 75,212 78,790
Income from government enterprises 4,195 4,566 4,423 4,065
Payments from the Federal Government 18,620 23,041 21,359 21,776
Other revenues 8,047 7,904 8,283 7,609
Total Budgetary Revenues 96,313 107,175 109,277 112,240
BUDGETARY EXPENDITURES
Community and social services 8,621 9,148 9,647 10,003
Education, training colleges and universities 27,818 28,568 30,506 31,401
Health and long-term care 43,054 44,414 47,269 48,369
Children and Youth Services 3,590 3,882 4,004 4,083
Community safety and security 2,137 2,218 2,278 2,315
Other Ministries Program spending 21,636 23,476 20,759 19,603
Total Budgetary Expenditures 106,856 111,706 114,463 115,774
OPERATING SURPLUS (DEFICIT) (10,543) (4,531) (5,186) (3,534)
PUBLIC DEBT INTEREST (8,719) (9,480) (10,097) (10,619)

ANNUAL BUDGETARY OPERATING
SURPLUS (DEFICIT) BEFORE RESERVE

(19,262) (14,011) (15,283) (14,153)
RESERVE - - - 1,000
ANNUAL BUDGETARY SURPLUS (DEFICIT) $(19,262) $(14,011) $(15,283) $(15,153)
TOTAL ONTARIO PUBLIC DEBT $ 193,589 $ 214,511 $ 237,583 $ 260,411
GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT (GDP) $581,635 $612,494 $638,169 $659,662
Net Ont. Public Debt as a % of Ont. GDP 33.3% 35.0% 37.2% 39.5%
Net debt per capita $ 14,809 $ 16,217 $ 17,766 $ 19,243
Population of Ontario (in thousands) 13,073 13,228 13,373 13,533

2.0.  PERSONAL TAXES top.gif (291 bytes)Top

2.1    Tax Rates top.gif (291 bytes)Top

The Budget proposes no changes to personal income tax rates. Accordingly, the top marginal rates for 2012 are as follows:

Type of Income
Federal
Ontario
Total
Eligible Dividends 19.3% 10.3% 29.6%
Non-Eligible Dividends 19.6% 13.0% 32.6%
Capital Gains 14.5% 8.7% 23.2%
Ordinary Income 29.0% 17.4% 46.4%

2.2    Individual Tax Creditstop.gif (291 bytes)Top

a) Ontario Drug Benefit(ODB)

The ODB partially pays for prescription drugs for Ontario seniors. Under current legislation, benefits are not income tested. There is an annual deductible of $100 per person and a patient co-payment of $6.11 per prescription. For low-income seniors, the deductible is waived and the co-payment reduced to $2 per prescription. The Budget proposes to introduce an income-based deductible, effective August 2014. For single seniors, the deductible will become $100 plus 3 per cent of net income in excess of $100,000. For senior couples, the deductible will become $200 plus 3 per cent of combined net income in excess of $160,000. The co-payment will remain at $6.11 per prescription. The reduction for lowincome seniors will be maintained.

b) Ontario Child Benefit (OCB)

The Budget proposes to increase the maximum OCB payments from $1,100 to $1,210 per child effective July 2013 with a further increase to $1,310 July 2014.

c) 30% Off Ontario Tuition Grant

This measure, which was announced in January 2012, provides a grant of up to $800 per term for a maximum of two terms per year for full-time undergraduate university or college degree students and up to $365 per term for a maximum of two terms for students enrolled in college diploma or certificate programs at publicly funded Ontario institutions. The Budget affirms the commitment to continuing this program.

d) Ontario Trillium Benefit (OTB)

The OTB, which combines the Ontario Sales Tax Credit, the Ontario Energy and Property Tax Credit and The Northern Ontario Energy Credit, provides Ontario low- to moderate income families with relief for taxes and energy costs. Starting July 2012, it will be paid monthly instead of quarterly, to assist eligible taxpayers to better manage their household budgets. The Budget proposes no changes to the OTB.

e) Healthy Homes Renovation Tax Credit (HHRTC)

The Budget confirms the HHRTC, which has already been introduced in the legislature. The HHRTC is a refundable tax credit of up to $1,500 per annum on expenditures for permanent home modifications to improve access for seniors or help a senior to be more mobile or functional in their home. The credit will be computed at 15 per cent of eligible expenditures to a maximum annual limit of $10,000 per annum per household. It will apply to expenditures after September 2011 and will be effective for 2012 and subsequent years. It is available to senior homeowners, tenants and people who share a home with a senior relative.

f) Ontario Clean Energy Benefit (OCEB)

The OCEB became effective January 1, 2011. It is a 10 per cent benefit applied on hydro billings and is intended to assist with rising energy costs. The Budget proposes to cap the OCEB to the cost of the first 3,000 kilowatt hours per month, effective September 1, 2012. This should not affect most residential households and small businesses but will cap the benefit for large users of electricity.

3.0 CORPORATE TAXES top.gif (291 bytes)Top

3.1    Tax Ratestop.gif (291 bytes)Top

The general corporate income tax rate is currently 11.5 per cent. It was to be reduced to 11 per cent July 1, 2012 and to 10 per cent July 1, 2013. The Budget proposes to temporarily freeze the rate at 11.5 per cent until such time as the budget is balanced (projected to be in 2017-18). Accordingly, Ontario corporate income tax rates are as follows:

General M&P Small
Business
11.5% 10.0% 4.5%

3.2    Business Education Tax (BET)top.gif (291 bytes)Top

In 2007 significant reductions in the BET over a seven year period were proposed. Significant reductions have taken place over the intervening period. The Budget proposes to temporarily freeze the BET reduction program, starting in 2013. It is intended to resume once the budget is balanced (projected to be in 2017-18). BET rate reductions which have been implemented will not be reversed.

3.3    Ontario Apprenticeship Training Tax Credit (OA TTC)top.gif (291 bytes)Top

The Budget indicates that the effectiveness and efficiency of the OATTC will be reviewed in terms of its promotion of apprenticeship completions with potential linking of the credit to apprenticeship completions.

3.4    Research and Development (R&D)top.gif (291 bytes)Top

The Budget indicates that the effectiveness of provincially provided R&D tax credits will continue to be reviewed. It is anticipated that the upcoming Federal Budget will make significant changes in this area which would impact on any provincial changes. The Jobs and Prosperity Council will be consulted on improvements to R&D tax support.

3.5    Employer Health Tax (EHT)top.gif (291 bytes)Top

Administrative practice in determining whether or not an employer/employee relationship exists will be strengthened. Federal rulings on the status of workers will continue to be used. However, Ontario will no longer be bound by such rulings for EHT purposes. This administrative practice change applies to EHT assessments issued after March 27, 2012.

3.6    Retail Sales Tax (RST) Refunds and Rebatestop.gif (291 bytes)Top

The Budget proposes to shorten the RST refund and rebate periods in order to accelerate the wind down of the RST system. Currently, refunds and rebates can be applied for until the time limits for claiming them have expired or June 30, 2014, whichever is earlier. The Budget requires that refund applications will have to be made on or before December 31, 2012. No changes are proposed for refund applications in respect of RST relating to insurance premiums and private transfers of used vehicles.

3.7    Loss Utilizationtop.gif (291 bytes)Top

Although each corporation in a corporate group currently must file separate tax returns, federal administrative practice facilitates an informal loss transfer system between corporations within the group in certain circumstances. Where all corporations do not operate in the same province, this can result in a slippage of revenue to a particular province. The Budget indicates that the province will work with the Federal government to ensure a fair and reasonable allocation of income.

4.0 TAX ADMINISTRATIONtop.gif (291 bytes)Top

4.1    Tax Collection Process top.gif (291 bytes)Top

The Budget proposes to amend the various tax statutes to enhance collection abilities including those of garnishment for monies to be loaned or advanced. In addition, technical amendments will be introduced to ensure that the deemed trust and enhanced garnishment provisions align with federal bankruptcy and insolvency laws.

In addition, the Budget proposes to implement measures requiring those who receive government grants and other forms of direct assistance to be tax compliant. Existing procurement requirements will be expanded to ensure that businesses cannot bid on provincially-funded projects and contracts unless they are tax compliant.

4.2    Corporate Tax Avoidance top.gif (291 bytes)Top

Arrangements that cause income or losses to be shifted across provincial or international borders can result in a significant erosion of the tax base. Consideration is being given to the implementation of measures similar to those introduced in Quebec to combat aggressive tax planning and particularly, interprovincial tax planning. The province will work with the Federal government to ensure that income is being properly allocated between provinces. If necessary, the government is prepared to introduce specific legislation to ensure that the province can evaluate and address interprovincial profit and loss shifting and inappropriate allocation of income between provinces.

4.3    Underground Economy top.gif (291 bytes)Top

The government proposes to adopt various measures to curb underground economy activities that result in the loss of tax revenue. The Budget provides a list of some of the potential measures the government is actively exploring.

5.0    TOBACCO TAX ACT top.gif (291 bytes)Top

The Budget proposes to review various potential changes to the Tobacco Tax Act to enhance enforcement measures. Any proposed changes will be the subject of consultations in conjunction with the Federal government and other provinces.

6.0    MINING TAX ACT top.gif (291 bytes)Top

The Budget indicates that a review of the Mining Tax Act will be undertaken to ensure its structure is still appropriate in the current tax environment and Ontario receives fair compensation for its non-renewable resources.

4211 Yonge Street. Suite 625 Toronto. Ontario M2P 2A9
Phone: (416) 636-7500 Toll Free: 1 (877) 871-4258 Fax: (416) 636-6545 Website: rznaccountants.com